Which VPN is best for OS X (macOS)? A practical, slightly geeky teardown
Choosing a VPN for macOS feels like buying a charger in an airport: there are a dozen options, marketing is loud, and one of them will probably work fine — but you want the one that won’t burn your laptop, sell your browsing habits, or turn your network into a mystery latency pit. I tested and researched the contenders, focusing on things that actually matter on macOS: native Apple Silicon support, notarized apps, kill-switch behavior, WireGuard support, privacy policy audits, and real-world speed.
Short verdict
For most macOS users the best overall balance of speed, privacy, and macOS polish is ExpressVPN. If you prioritize absolute auditability and open-source clients, pick ProtonVPN or Mullvad. If you want a powerful, feature-rich bargain, Surfshark or Private Internet Access (PIA) are excellent choices.
Quick comparison
| VPN | macOS app (Apple Silicon) | Privacy / Audit | Speed Protocols | Starting price | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ExpressVPN | Native app, notarized, good UI | Independent audits transparency reports | Lightning-fast, Lightway OpenVPN | ~6.67/mo (annual) | expressvpn.com |
| NordVPN | Apple Silicon app, polished | Multiple audits, Advanced privacy features | WireGuard (NordLynx), fast | ~3.29/mo (promo) | nordvpn.com |
| ProtonVPN | Native, open-source client | Strong transparency, open-source | WireGuard, good speeds | Free tier paid from ~4/mo | protonvpn.com |
| Surfshark | Apple Silicon, user-friendly | Audited, budget-friendly | WireGuard support, competitive speeds | ~2.49/mo (long-term) | surfshark.com |
| PIA (Private Internet Access) | Native app, highly configurable | Transparent logs history, court-tested | WireGuard/OpenVPN, advanced settings | ~2.19/mo (sale) | privateinternetaccess.com |
| Mullvad | Simple native app, privacy-first | Open-source, minimal account model | WireGuard-focused, fast | €5/mo flat | mullvad.net |
What macOS users should care about (short checklist)
- Native Apple Silicon support: Apple’s M1/M2 chips benefit from native builds for performance and battery life.
- Notarization / App-signed: Notarized apps reduce Gatekeeper friction and improve safety.
- Kill switch that actually kills: macOS sleep/wake and network interface quirks can leak if the kill switch is flaky.
- Modern protocols: WireGuard or equivalent (Lightway, NordLynx) for speed and stability.
- Privacy guarantees: independent audits, transparent policies, where the company is legally based.
- Minimal system-level annoyances: avoid VPNs that force kernel extensions or weird routing hacks on modern macOS.
Deep dives — what each contender brings to macOS
ExpressVPN — the polished, reliable option (best overall)
Why it’s here: ExpressVPN nails the user experience on macOS. The app is familiar, simple, Apple-notarized, and offers a lightweight protocol called Lightway that’s optimized for speed and reconnection (handy when you switch from Wi‑Fi to mobile hotspot). The company publishes a trust center with audits and transparency reports, which matters more than ad-speak.
Mac-specific notes: Solid kill switch, good handling of sleep/wake, and a simple server picker. Slightly pricier than some rivals but often the least fiddly.
NordVPN — high performance security features
Why it’s here: Nord’s macOS client is mature, supports Apple Silicon, and includes advanced features (Double VPN, Threat Protection). NordLynx (their WireGuard variant) gives consistently strong speeds. The company publicizes audits and has improved transparency over time.
Mac-specific notes: Great for users who want a blend of speed and security features. The UI is busier than ExpressVPN’s — more knobs if you like that kind of thing.
ProtonVPN — open-source and privacy-first
Why it’s here: ProtonVPN is from the ProtonMail team, emphasizes transparency, and offers an open-source macOS client. There’s a generous free tier (with limited speeds/locations) if you want to test without handing over payment info.
Mac-specific notes: Excellent for users who prioritize open-source code, with a clear privacy stance and solid WireGuard support.
Surfshark — powerful features at a low price
Why it’s here: Surfshark combines good speeds, modern WireGuard support, and a neat feature set (multi-hop, ad-blocking) at a very competitive price. Their macOS client is well-designed and supports Apple Silicon.
Mac-specific notes: Great value for shared households or families — unlimited simultaneous devices is a killer feature.
PIA — the configurator’s choice
Why it’s here: Private Internet Access is popular with power users. It’s highly configurable (DNS, custom routing, port selection) and has a long track record. The client is native and supports WireGuard.
Mac-specific notes: If you want to tune every parameter, PIA is satisfying if you want “set-and-forget”, it’s still fine but a little more technical.
Mullvad — minimal, privacy-first, and honest
Why it’s here: Mullvad’s model is refreshingly simple: no emails, accounts are numbered IDs, and the client is open-source. It’s aimed at privacy purists and offers straightforward pricing.
Mac-specific notes: The macOS app is lightweight and focused. Not the sleekest UX, but technically sound and privacy-respecting.
Performance and real-world testing notes
Real-world speeds on macOS will depend on location, ISP, whether you use WireGuard/NordLynx/Lightway, and Wi‑Fi vs wired. In testing across multiple geographies, WireGuard-based services (NordLynx, Mullvad, ProtonVPN, Surfshark) tend to be fastest for raw throughput. ExpressVPN’s Lightway competes closely and is often more resilient during network transitions (handy for laptop mobility).
Security caveats specific to macOS
- macOS sleep/wake leaks: Some VPNs momentarily leak when waking from sleep if the kill switch doesn’t re-engage quickly. Watch for this if you frequently close your laptop lid.
- Kernel extensions vs Network Extensions: Apple prefers Network Extension-based VPNs over old kernel extensions modern apps should avoid kernel kexts for compatibility and security.
- Notarization by Apple: Not a guarantee of perfect security, but it avoids install friction and reduces malware risk.
Recommendations by user type
- The everyday user: ExpressVPN — smooth, fast, and painless.
- The privacy purist: Mullvad or ProtonVPN — open-source clients and minimal data collection.
- The power user / tinkerer: PIA — deep configuration options.
- The budget-conscious family: Surfshark — unlimited devices and strong speed for the price.
Useful links references
- ExpressVPN — official site and trust center: https://www.expressvpn.com and https://www.expressvpn.com/trust
- NordVPN — official site: https://nordvpn.com
- ProtonVPN — official site and transparency: https://protonvpn.com
- Surfshark — official site: https://surfshark.com
- Private Internet Access — official site: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com
- Mullvad — official site: https://mullvad.net
- Independent comparisons and reviews: That One Privacy Site, PCMag VPN roundup
Final thoughts
macOS users don’t need to overcomplicate this: pick a provider with a native Apple Silicon app, a trustworthy privacy posture, and modern protocols (WireGuard or equivalents). ExpressVPN offers the smoothest, least-annoying experience for most people ProtonVPN, Mullvad, and PIA are excellent if you lean toward open-source transparency or deep configuration. Surfshark is the smart wallet-friendly choice for shared households.
Remember: a VPN improves privacy on the network layer but is not a silver bullet — browser fingerprinting, site login tracking, and app telemetry still exist. Combine a solid VPN with good browser hygiene and you’ll sleep better than your laptop after a successful software update.
Be the first to leave a comment